| Year | Recipient | High School | College |
| 2008 | Colby K. Fisher | Union-Endicott High School, Endicott, NY | Syracuse University |
| 2008 | Joshua R. Jett | Riverbend High School, Fredericksburg, VA | Messiah College |
| 2007 | Kathlina M. Young | Walkersville High School, Walkersville, MD | Salisbury University |
| 2006 | Venessa L. Bailey | Danville Area High School, Danville, PA | University of Pittsburgh |
| 2005 | Alexander W. Seebeck | Loudon Valley High School, Purcellville, VA | UNC at Asheville |